Drug Deaths 2018, Early Data from the CDC

Within hours of posting my previous article regarding projected deaths for drug overdoses, the CDC reported their early data on drug deaths for 2018. [I don't consider the CDC data to be finalized until it has been added to the Wonder Database (CDC Wonder Database).] Nevertheless, according to the CDC, there was drop in the number of drug related deaths from 2017 to 2018. And as an added bonus, there was a slight rise in US life expectancy. 

Here's one of the better articles I came across that explains the CDC data is from Vox: https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2020/1/30/21111887/opioid-epidemic-drug-overdose-death-2018

The article reported that the crude rate (number of deaths per 100,000) had decreased to 20.7 in 2018 from 21.7 in 2017. I reviewed all my past data analysis and predictions to see how this new data lined up with of my predictions. Here's what I found:

1. My best fit model that used data from 1999 to 2016 predicted that the crude rate for 2017 and 2018 would be 18.4 and 19.0 respectively. These predictions are strikingly lower than the actual data. And I should mention that this model is a second order, curvilinear, accelerating rate model.
2. My best fit worst case scenario model that used data from 2008 to 2016 predicted 20.1 for 2017 and 23.4 for 2018. Slightly low for 2017 but noticeably high for 2018. Again, this is a second order, curvilinear, accelerating rate model. The rate of acceleration is greater than the model above.
3. My best fit model using the most recent CDC Wonder data from 1999 to 2017 suggested that the crude rate for 2018 would be 27.5. This is a much faster accelerating 4th order model.

Analysis

The apparent primary cause for the striking rise in the death rate for 2017 was due to the increasing availability and use of illegal fentanyl. If the US is going be able to stem the tide of this epidemic, efforts are going to need to be made to reduce the many deaths from fentanyl and its chemical cousins. Is that happening? Consider the follow chart from the Vox article. 

Some of the decrease in drug death rates are likely due to the increased availability of the opioid overdose antidote, naloxone. There's a noticeable down-tick in the death rates across all drug categories suggesting a common factor of influence crossing all categories. However, although all other curves show a downturn in the death rate, deaths due to synthetic opioids (most notably fentanyl) continues to rise although at a lower rate.

So, are we seeing the light at the end of the tunnel of the opioid epidemic? Or is this just the light of a train coming the other direction? The cause for appears to be the reduction in deaths from heroin and natural and semisynthetic opioids. However, the rate of death from synthetic opioids continues to climb and this is the predominant cause of death from drug overdoses. Thus it's clear, this is not anywhere near to being under control.

I'll conclude by quoting from the Vox article that suggests that the underlying causes of the epidemic as well as the supply of drugs remain and remain unaddressed:

... the country still seems to struggle with underlying conditions that experts say are fueling “deaths of despair.” That’s not just drug overdoses but also suicides, which increased in 2018, and alcohol-related deaths, which have doubled in the past two decades. ...

“If all of these social factors were there, and we didn’t have the supply of drugs, of course people would not be dying of overdoses,” Nora Volkow, director of the National Institute on Drug Abuse, previously told me. “But it is the confluence of the widespread markets of drugs — that are very accessible and very potent — and the social-cultural factors that are making people despair and seek out these drugs as a way of escaping.”

All of that leaves America vulnerable to increases in drug addiction cases and overdose deaths, even as it sees some gains due to drops in opioid prescriptions and related deaths.

Update: Public Health Alert: Centers for Disease Control: 2017 and Projections to 2025

I've published two articles in this blog related to drug related deaths. Since then, I've gone back to CDC's Wonder Database (https://wonder.cdc.gov) in order to use their most recent data to rework my models and predictions. What I found shocked me. As you will see below, the number of death reported by the New York Times in the linked article was not 72,300 as reported. It was 73,990 in 2017. The number that the Times reported was well beyond the number that I had predicted in my worst case scenario for 2017 of 69,000 drug related deaths. The updated year 2017 number I extracted from Wonder showed that my worst case number of drug related deaths for 2017 was low by an additional 1700 deaths for a total prediction error of: low by 3,990 deaths. 

Putting my error in perspective: approximately 2240 died in the Pearl Harbor attack; in the 9/11 attacks, 2, 977 people died; from 774 SARS around 2004 and that was a world-wide health crisis; I could go on. This cannot be considered anything other than a catastrophic crisis. 

Going Back to the Source

I decided to go back to the Wonder database and reexamine the drug death data.  This time I included the actual data from 2017 to see how the new data would effect my original predictions.

I queried Wonder for all the drug-related deaths from 1999 to 2017. To understand trends, the best measure is the "crude rate." Crude rate is the number of deaths per 100,000 population. It's similar to a percentage of the population, but instead of 100 being the denominator, it's 100,000.

The results are shown below.

1999 to 2017 Drug Related Deaths (CDC Wonder)

I recalculated my trend line and found that a 4th order equation provided by far the best fit for the data. In fact this trend line appears to provide a nearly perfect description of the data. My original  trend lines (including my worst case trend line) were second order equations. The worst case trend line was based on the data from 2008 to 2016. On the other hand new equation was based on all the available data. The last two years have shown a substantial uptick in the crude rate. 

The actual number of drug related deaths for 1999 to 2017 is shown below. The chart lists the actual number of deaths for each year.

1999 to 2017 Drug Related Deaths (CDC Wonder)

Based on this data we can clear see the effects of the widespread availability and use of fentanyl. 

Projecting Into the Future

Based on the new data and the recalculated trend line, what are the predictions for the crude rate and the number of drug related deaths from 2017 to 2025. 

Using the new equation, I projected might be expected for the future. That is shown in the two charts below.

Projected Crude and Number of Drug Related Deaths to 2025

I want to make clear that these are my projections, not the CDC or another organization. I also want to mention is that the last time I made future projections for drug related deaths, that even my worst case projections were substantially lower than what the actual data would show. So as bad as these numbers are, I consider them not out of the realm of possibility. Nevertheless, based on the equation the actual crude rate data, drug related deaths last year (2019) were over 100,000. And the number of drug related deaths could reach over 400,000 by 2025. That is a staggeringly high number and would make the opioid crisis the origination point for the worst epidemic in US history. With numbers like these US life expectancy will continue to trend downward at an accelerating rate. 

My sense is that the drug related death rate will at some point level out or stop growing at this extremely high rate. However, as of this point, based on the data so far, these are the projections. It will take a couple of years, but I would be interested in knowing the actual number of drug related deaths that occurred in 2019. If the number is anywhere near 100,000, then it's clear that we are riding on a trend line of massively high numbers of drug related deaths into the future. 

Public Health Alert: Centers for Disease Control records 72,300 Drug Related Deaths in 2017

Here is the article from the New York Times reporting the number of drug related deaths from the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) for 2017.

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/15/upshot/opioids-overdose-deaths-rising-fentanyl.html?em_pos=small&emc=edit_up_20180815&nl=upshot&nl_art=0&nlid=67594383emc%3Dedit_up_20180815&ref=headline&te=1

In my own analysis https://professionalpredictivemodels.blogspot.com/2018/07/drugs-deaths-1999-to-2016-and.html my worst case prediction was for approximately 69,000 in 2017. To have a worst case exceeded by over 3000 deaths is a stunning development. My worst case prediction for 2018 is for the number of deaths to be between 76,000 and 77,000. And by 2025 my worst case prediction is for the number of drug related deaths to be between 150,000 and 160,000. I have had a difficult time believing the trends that the numbers appear to show. They seem unbelievable, but given that my own worst case, my own worst fears have been outstripped by the actual numbers ... well it now it appears that my own worst case fears may exceeded by reality.

Drugs Deaths: 1999 to 2016 and Predicting Outcomes in Future Years

I write another (new) blog that dedicated to statistical analysis of a variety of sources of data and to predictive models. I recently wrote an article that is public health related. Although it has nothing to do with medical devices, it nevertheless is related to public health, treatment and sorry to say, death rates.

Here's the link to the article.

https://professionalpredictivemodels.blogspot.com/2018/07/drugs-deaths-1999-to-2016-and.html

Here is a preview:

The Centers for Disease Control (CDC) has a comprehensive online database known as Wonder (https://wonder.cdc.gov) that is accessible to all. So if you have public health related questions, the data to answer them can be found in Wonder.

Unless you've been living under a rock, you know that deaths from drug overdoses particularly opioid related deaths have been steady increasing. I am interested in not only in the number of deaths, but the rate of increase and what that suggests for the future. I believe you will find the results of my analysis both interesting and troubling, particularly for the future.

Here's a chart showing the number deaths from 1999 to 2016:

...

Using the equation derived from the 2008 to 2016 data, the picture that arises is much more concerning. In fact the crude rate in 2025 is twice the rate predicted by the trend line equation derived from the 1999 to 2016 data. This suggests that the number of drug related deaths would be near 500,000 by the mid 2020s and that the number of drug related deaths during the 2020s would be closer to 1 million to 1,500,000 where the number of deaths per year would be no less than 100,000 and possibly up to 150,000 each year. Most of these deaths would come about as a result of opioid overdoses.